Victorian Popular Fictions 7.2.8 Maltz

 

“Here presented nonsequentially, and in a new relation to one another”: Primary Source Work and the Quest for Empathy in Tom Crewe’s The New Life

Diana Maltz

Download PDF here

Abstract

Tom Crewe’s 2023 novel The New Life reconstructs the collaboration between sexologist Havelock Ellis and cultural critic John Addington Symonds as they wrote their 1897 study Sexual Inversion. Historically, Sexual Inversion was banned in 1898 following an obscenity trial the homophobia of which bore the imprint of the Wilde Trials in 1895. Arguably, The New Life comprises an experiment in affective historiography. Crewe, a trained historian, draws upon authentic letters, memoirs and treatises. These texts prompt protagonists’ crises and self-discovery; they wince at or surrender to or resist their authority. Crewe appeals to us via emotional resonances in his writing and validates our ways of connecting with historical materials. Yet Crewe also undermines readers’ presentist desires for queer characters to express gay pride; instead, he shows how outing oneself in the 1890s might feel liberatory but endangers one’s companions. Crewe’s project thus mirrors late-Victorian efforts at feeling. He invokes a socialist association, the Fellowship of the New Life (1883-97), whose adherents promoted self-perfection through radical compassion. As he designs his plot and develops protagonists’ interior lives, Crewe centres empathy as much as late-Victorian ethical socialists did.

Keywords

Tom Crewe; The New Life; Havelock Ellis; John Addington Symonds; Sexual Inversion; Bedborough Trial; Wilde Trials; textual quotation; affective historiography

Date of Acceptance: 22 September 2025

Date of Publication: 19 December 2025

Double Blind Peer Reviewed

Recommended Citation: 

Maltz, Diana. 2025. “‘Here presented nonsequentially, and in a new relation to one another’: Primary Source Work and the Quest for Empathy in Tom Crewe’s The New Life.” Victorian Popular Fictions, 7.2 (Autumn): 128-44. ISSN: 2632-4253 (online) DOI: https://doi.org/10.46911/INZW8753

Return to Contents page of VPFJ 7.2

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License