Simon Young, The Nail in the Skull and Other Victorian Urban Legends. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 2022, 230 pp. $35.00 (paperback). ISBN 978-1-4968-3946-6
Reviewed by Helena Ifill
Recommended citation: Ifill, Helena. 2024. Review of The Nail in the Skull and Other Victorian Urban Legends, Victorian Popular Fictions, 6.2: 135-136. ISSN: 2632-4253 (online) DOI: https://doi.org/10.46911/SBHO1894
The majority of Simon Young’s The Nail in the Skull is a collection of urban legends as printed in newspapers and other popular media. For the most part, Young includes only one or two versions of each legend (usually a paragraph or two), briefly noting variations that appear elsewhere. Several of the legends are as horrible as the book’s title suggests, featuring a range of traumatic experiences and gruesome scenarios (such as “Beetle Eyes,” which tells of parents who bandage beetles to their children’s eyes to blind them, making them more effective, because more pitiable, beggars). Other legends relate to issues such as love and money, and are sometimes humorous. For example, in “Hands in the Muff” there is confusion about whose hand is touching whose. Young also points out that the range of stories allows for rare insight into Victorian social groups that did not get much social recognition, such as ‘“toshers,’ sewer treasure-seekers” who feature in, and were transmitters of, the legend of “Sewer Monsters” (xxv).
Young is clear about the scope of his book, which is “an admittedly partial handlist of nineteenth-century British legends” which he does not attempt to “analyze” (xxiv), rather seeing collections such as this as “classificatory works” which “orient and direct research,” and “give glimpses of the ecosystem in which such legends develop” (xxv). Indeed, partial as it may be, there is a wealth of material in The Nail in the Skull, and the anthological nature of the book results in many tantalising lines of enquiry that readers may wish to follow for themselves. For example, many of the stories are taken from American media, which invites contemplation of the transatlantic circulation of urban legends. There are also numerous references to pre- and post-Victorian sources, which demonstrate the longevity and range of urban legends, but also raise questions about what is distinctively Victorian about those which appear in Britain during the period.
The access Young provides to stories which were clearly commonly known to many Victorians but “were not collected or studied in Victorian times” nor have been “for the most part […] collected or studied since” (xxi) is where the book’s primary purpose and significance lies. However, Young’s introduction is informative, discussing how urban legends were transmitted, both in print and orally, and usefully situating that transmission alongside Victorian cultural developments such as increased literacy. The introduction also suggests why urban legends may be of interest to scholars other than folklorists. Young defines urban legends as “explorations of belief” in which “the reader or listener wonders about the truth of the story” (xxi, emphasis in original). Their appearance in newspapers and magazines as “strange stories,” often anecdotal in tone, brings them very close to the short fiction appearing in periodicals. Indeed, as Young explains, the boundaries between fact and fiction were sometimes left deliberately indistinct, meaning it was not always clear if the reader was encountering “fiction masquerading as news, news masquerading as fiction, or some uneasy hybrid” (xxxiii). The recurrence of strange stories in different print media is also a point of interest for those concerned with the periodical press. In terms of content, Young explains that these stories “touch on extreme or difficult aspects of life: crime, death, illness, sex, the supernatural, and war” (xxii), and this means that they are a way of allowing “society” to “run […] through its concerns in compelling and easily shared narratives” (xxii). In this way, they function similarly to literary genres such as the Gothic. Moreover, as Young notes (xxxiii), the plots of many of these urban legends may seem familiar to readers of Victorian popular fiction, particularly those with interests in the short story and penny bloods. “Human Sausages,” for example, is a variation of what James Malcolm Rymer would expand into The String of Pearls (1846–47). There are also several tropes that are recognisable from popular fiction (then and now), such as the drugging of victims with chloroform (“Chloroformed!”), and stories that will resonate with researchers interested in a wide range of Victorian topics from Imperialism (e.g. “Harem Prisoner”) to science (e.g. “The Tell-Tale Eye”, concerning the image of a victim’s murderer being recorded on their retina at the moment of death). Other stories, including those which continue in some form to this day (such as sewer monsters, mentioned above), and the example of a Victorian chain letter (“A Million Postage Stamps”) also serve to make this book fascinating to read in its own right.
In the preface, Young explains his process in searching through digital archives which (unlike other folklorists’ keyword searches relating to particular legends) involved searching for phrases such as “strange story” and “horrible story” (xiii) which commonly appear in the titles or descriptions of urban legends in newspaper reports. The result is that many sources have identical or very similar titles (there are ten entries beginning with some variation on “A Horrible Story” in the bibliography, for example), and Young’s careful and clear referencing with such a mass of material should be acknowledged. This also allowed Young (after sifting through “thousands of news reports”) to discover previously unknown sources and stories (xiii). This is therefore an important book that gathers a vast range of Victorian urban legends, and allows readers to pursue individual stories further should they wish.
While being thoroughly researched and referenced, the subject matter and format means that it is also readable and entertaining. As well as being of scholarly interest to VPFJ readers, therefore, this book would prove an excellent gift for anyone interested in the history of Victorian popular culture.
Return to Contents page of issue 6.2
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
