Helena Esser interviews Roy Bayfield about the most VPFA book club ever
On YouTube, Roy Reads Anything heads up a year-long read-along that will be right up the VPFA members’ alley: We’ve got Marryat, we’ve got Lytton, we’ve got Corelli, we’ve got Ouida, and many more that may still be on your To-Be-Read list! And there’s merch, too! In today’s blog, Roy tells you everything about his Neglected Victorian Bestsellers project, and how he’s helping them find new readers and fans – and he’s inviting us all to come along. Learn more about the Victorian BookTube community, ponder the popular in today’s social media landscape, join a fun group project, and discover some bestsellers that are niche even for you!
About Roy: Following previous existences as a night-club cleaner, university marketing director and psychogeographer, Roy Bayfield has concentrated on scouring ancient archives for obscure material. Taking a Masters in Nineteenth Century Studies at Edge Hill University initiated him into the endless delights of the Victorian period. He lives in seclusion with his wife Jennie in a town whose name means Church of the Worm. His BookTube channel @royreadsanything explores various genres but leans toward Victorian fiction and magazines.
Neglected Victorian Bestsellers is an online participative reading project.
Videos can be found at this link, with extra discussion on Discord – there’s even beautiful merch!
The 2026 reads are:
- Ouida, Under Two Flags
- Charlotte Mary Yonge, The Heir of Redclyffe
- Florence Marryat, The Blood of the Vampire
- Marie Corelli, A Romance of Two Worlds
- James Payn, Lost Sir Massingberd
- T. Meade and Robert Eustace, The Brotherhood of the Seven Kings
- Ann S. Stephens, Malaeska
- Dick Donovan, A Detective’s Triumphs
- W. M. Reynolds, Mysteries of London
- Walter Besant, In Luck at Last
- Various, The Fate of Fenella
- H. Dana, Two Years Before the Mast
- Bulwer Lytton, A Strange Story
First things first: What is the Neglected Victorian Bestsellers project and how is it going? How can people join?
Basically it’s a sort of reading group with YouTube as its main location. The topic is books that were once very popular, although critics may not have liked them — but for whatever reasons they have almost disappeared. Even if the author names are known they aren’t being read. Books have been selected in advance for each month of the year and I front it up by making teaser videos about the authors and sharing thoughts after reading the book. All of this is free and accessible to anyone who can watch YouTube content. Some folks add comments to these videos or talk about the books on their own channels if they have them. There is also a group on Discord where a bunch of us share thoughts and related material. Given that I thought I might be doing this on my own I’d say it’s going great, with a lot of engagement ranging from social chat to in-depth analysis.
What made you want to explore forgotten reader favourites from that era?
Curiosity really. It amazes me how some writers have dropped off the radar. Many of these sold in huge numbers, even outselling writers who have remained in the public mind. I was curious to see if works by the likes of Ouida, Florence Marryat and Walter Besant could still be enjoyed. The answer so far is a resounding yes, though sometimes the modern reader needs to invest a bit of time in adapting to writing styles that have fallen out of fashion.
What makes the ‘popular’ aspect of them interesting?
Despite the disdain of critics, people were reading these works — penny fiction, imported Dime Novels, yellowbacks and the kind of books that were the life-blood of circulating libraries. So from the point of view of anyone interested in the era, there is something exciting about venturing beyond the canon to explore what the teeming millions read on a daily basis. Everyone from the apocryphal office boys and shop girls to Queen Victoria were reading texts that critics looked down on then and that are rarely read now. It’s like looking through new lenses onto the period.
How did you choose your authors and books?
Various sources indicated who was popular and my initial process was to find out more about authors I hadn’t read. In some cases I knew the names but with no real idea about what they had written. I aimed for an even gender balance and fairly short books that I was interested in reading myself. The BookTube community has a fondness for alliteration and puns in the titles of reading events, such as Dr November (espionage books), March of the Mammoths (800-plus pages) and Shaketember (Shakespeare). So I tried to have a bit of that flavour with Marie Corelli March, Meade in May and so on. Although it’s the ‘Victorian’ period some authors were not subjects of the British monarch; I’ve cast the net as widely as possible.
Why did you choose YouTube as your platform?
I started making videos on YouTube a few years ago. I had bought one of those bundles of old books that are sold by the metre for decoration, with the idea of actually reading them, and wanted a platform to talk about this little adventure. I found that there was a sort of loose community of people making bookish-themed videos, with ‘BookTube’ as an umbrella term. After a while I got absorbed into the BookTube community, made many friends and had a lot of fun. One thing that happens in BookTube is ‘events’, where someone (usually a small group of ‘hosts’) facilitates a themed reading time that anyone can join in with. Usually there are ‘prompts’ or ‘challenges’ for types of books to read within the theme. One of the longer-established ones is Victober, a month reading Victorian fiction: novelist Katie Lumsden was one of its originators. In 2025 I was delighted to be invited to be one of an expanded group of co-hosts assembled, Avengers style, for the Victober’s tenth anniversary. This was massive fun and, rather than just stop cold turkey, I wanted to do something Victorian-themed for the rest of the year. Normally videos that I make get about 200—300 views but the introduction to Neglected Victorian Bestsellers got over 4,000 and some of the bigger channels were talking about it, so relatively speaking it is a popular project!
What are some responses you’re getting from readers? Are the novels finding new fans, do you think?
There are certainly some authors that most respondents have liked. Ouida, Florence Marryat and Marie Corelli have all proved to be enjoyable, notwithstanding their occasional eccentricities. Charlotte Mary Yonge’s work did not receive universal acclaim though we were all glad to have read something by her (The Heir of Redclyffe) and to have a sense of where she fits in.
So far, have you been surprised by the novels you’ve read?
Often! I find the resonance between each authors’ style of celebrity and their actual work intriguing. They seem totally happy to break the fourth wall and buttonhole the reader with some opinion or theory. And their plots are wild — improbable melodrama, vampires at the seaside, electric potions — what’s not to like?
Which one are (or were) you looking forward to the most?
I have a good feeling about our April pick, Lost Sir Massingberd by James Payn. The author seems to be completely forgotten by readers, academics, more or less everyone — but everything I’ve dug up suggests that he was a reliably entertaining and amusing writer.
Why do you think these novels were big hits in their time, and what made them fall out of favour?
These writers conjured up strong characters and spun compelling plots with attractive hooks. Some tapped into the sensation current with hints of immorality. There is also an effervescent engagement with modernity, with themes such as leisure and electricity. Readers may have felt they were tapping into some kind of grand authorial wisdom, whether it is Bulwer-Lytton’s voluminous scholarship, Corelli’s mysticism, Yonge’s High Anglicanism or Ouida’s implied knowledge of high society. So the books provide escape into larger worlds coupled with a sense that they’re worthwhile reading. However as time went on I guess people saw them as old hat. I’ve read early twentieth-century press cuttings about a stage version of Ouida’s Under Two Flags, some decades after the book came out. They characterise the original readers as their grandmother’s generation who thought they were reading something shocking, the naive old things!
Do these novels deserve a resurgence, or do they belong to their time?
Both really. They deserve a resurgence because they are of their time and tell us something about it. Of course that includes some terrible ideas and attitudes.
Do you see parallels between Victorian pop culture and today?
Definitely, particularly the way authors created brands for themselves and used multiple channels to build their celebrity. I think a lot of the writers we’re looking at positioned themselves to take advantage of developments in production and distribution, writing whatever worked in new markets: short stories, serials, one-volume novels and so on. Some of these guys were editors as well as authors, which gave them more of a presence in the media they relied on as authors. I love that there was cosplay too, with people dressing up as characters like Cigarette from Under Two Flags for tableaux, floats and fancy dress! Marie Corelli riding a gondola on the River Avon is classic social media content creation.